Roku Streaming Player Review (Why I Chose It Over Apple TV)

I’ve been using Apple computers since 1989 and have been buying them since 1993. I have not have just Macs in my home, but an iPhone and iPad as well. Yet, when it came to buying a product to connect the Internet to my TV, I chose a Roku instead of Apple TV.

I’m still surprised myself that I chose to not stick with the Apple branding. However, when I compared the two choices, it seemed like I wouldn’t be getting everything I wanted from the Apple TV. To get what I wanted, I had to go with the Roku. Now having used the Roku, I haven’t regretted that decision once.


The largest stumbling block with the Apple TV is that it only works with HDTV. Sure, some people have found some workarounds, but they don’t seem like altogether good options. While searching for the Apple TV on Amazon, I found the Roku. Unlike Apple, it can be used on either HDTV or standard. I decided it was my best option, and then had to decide between the three Roku models. I’m not a big gamer, and that seemed to be the selling point of the most expensive model. Since the only difference between the mid-range and low-range models was high-definition, my decision was already made for me.


When you’re used to cable boxes and DVDs, the Roku seems very small. It’s not much bigger than a hockey puck. It comes with the power cord, an AV cable to connect it to a standard TV, and a remote. If you’re connecting to HDTV, or if you don’t have wireless Internet, those cables can be purchased separately. After plugging the Roku in, it displays a screen that asks you to enter a short code on the Roku website on your computer. Once you do this and start a Roku account, the setup is complete. You will need a credit card to set up your account, but the only time you will be charged is if you decide to purchase content or channels. The included remote allows you to select channels, play, pause, forward, reverse, etc.


There are a handful of channels already included on your Roku, such as Netflix, Hulu, Pandora, and Facebook, but more can be added. Some of the additional changes you can add are free, and some of them will cost a few dollars. Likewise, some of the services on these channels charge a monthly fee, such as Netflix, and some of them are free, such as Pandora.

With the entertainment channels, you can stream movies and TV episodes to your television. With Pandora, you can stream music that matches your tastes. What I particularly enjoy is streaming photos from my Facebook account, both my own and those of the people on my Friends list. It’s something I’m using the Roku for that I didn’t expect to.


If you have an iOS device, such as an iPhone or iPad, you can download a Roku app to act as the remote. It can make it a little more handy since you are most likely already sitting with your device next to you anyway. It’s only slightly clunkier to use, and it eliminates the need for one more device to be sitting next to you.

What I miss out on by not getting the Apple TV is not having streaming access to my iTunes library. That was the only reason I considered not getting the Roku. In the end, I decided if I could listen to my music on all my other devices, it wasn’t that important. And I don’t download TV and movies from iTunes anyway, just music. I can still listen to music I enjoy on Pandora. I hated to break away from my tradition of Apple, but for my uses, the Roku was the most sound decision, and after purchasing it, I haven’t regretted the decision.

What about you? Would you prefer Roku or Apple TV?

Laura Tucker Laura Tucker

Laura has spent nearly 20 years writing news, reviews, and op-eds, with more than 10 of those years as an editor as well. She has exclusively used Apple products for the past three decades. In addition to writing and editing at MTE, she also runs the site's sponsored review program.


  1. I enjoyed reading the article, but I am going to have to disagree with a few points. If your using iTunes to buy and or manage music, then there is a bunch your missing out on, like Airplay for video/audo/amd photos. Yes, facebook photo streaming is cool, but I will bet that is only a software update away. I hear you on the HD thing, but the problem with that is EVERY TV you buy now in EVERY size is HD. Not to mention its got great support via iTunes since most anything new is in HD. Yes the Apple TV does Netflix too; as well as YouTube and Viemo. An NHL, MLB, and NBA broadband support. There is also Bluetooth and 5ghz 802.11 built into the Apple TV so it has great network support. The best part? It’s running iOS 5 which means you know Apple is going to let you have Apps on it at some point. An that meas sky’s the limit.

    1. I understand completely what you’re saying, and they’re all valid points. I deliberated over the choice for a long time. We are watching more movies and TV on the Roku than listening to music, though. I’m either streaming Pandora, or watching movies and TV on the Roku. And yes, all new TVs are HD, but that leaves out the people who don’t have a new TV. We have five TVs in this house, and none of them are HD. I wasn’t about to buy a new TV just to use the AppleTV, and I was afraid to spend the money on it without knowing if the HD workaround I’d read about would work. Trust me, I waited for the AppleTV for a year, and when I finally sat down to buy it and fully researched it out, I just couldn’t justify it.

  2. Sorry, but it worked for about 2 weeks and then nothing, I had bought two and they both were a flop, you have to remember your email address and codes each and every time a default… way to much of a headache..sorry i cant recommend this device..  living nightmare

    1. Perhaps you set up the Roku the wrong way. I didn’t have that eexperience at all. Mine is still working very well after five months, and I didn’t have to put my email and passwords in every time I used it it.

Comments are closed.