Chrome OS vs. Windows 10 S: Which Is Right for You?

With Microsoft introducing the new version of its operating system, Windows 10 S, a new player entered the market of budget laptops and PCs. This segment of the market was previously ruled by Chromebooks, low-cost laptops (starting from $179) that are running Google’s Chrome OS. However, Google has a new rival: Microsoft.

Windows 10 S is quite similar in look and design to Windows 10. Microsoft described the company’s new budget operating system as a “specific configuration of Windows 10 Pro that offers a familiar, productive Windows experience that’s streamlined for security and performance.” However, there are major differences.

windows-10-s-start-menu

Windows 10 S will only allow you to download and use apps from the Windows Store. This rids the experience from the traditional ways to install software. The downside of this feature is that not all applications can be found in the Windows Store. For example, if you would like to use Adobe PhotoShop CS6 to edit images, you can’t find it in Microsoft’s applications. Of course, alternatives are offered: the free PhotoShop Express and PhotoShop Elements 15, the latter costing you $99.

Microsoft argues that such changes were necessary to improve the security of the new system. By using the apps exclusively from the Windows Store, users can avoid the spread of malware to the OS.

In addition, the tighter control over the installed applications makes the system lightweight, meaning that it will run faster on devices with low-end hardware. By installing applications only from the Windows Store, it will prevent the system from slowing down over time. This slowdown is often caused by apps demanding a larger part of the system resources as well as cruft building up in the start up sequences.

Apps Installation

While Windows 10 S uses the traditional ways to install applications (from the hard drive), Chrome OS uses the Internet for almost everything. In the early years of Chrome OS, it was almost impossible to use the operating system in offline mode. However, later on Google released a number of programs which allow you to work offline and sync with web servers when you connect to a WiFi network. You can download applications from the Google Play Store, although every move is conducted through browser windows with both apps and user data residing in the cloud.

Browser

Taking advantage of the lightweight system, both OSes limit the number of search engines and browsers that can be used. Obviously and evidently, the Chrome OS offers Google Chrome for the browser and Google as the search engine, while Windows 10 S comes with Microsoft Edge and Bing.

Other than preferences, there shouldn’t be any problem with Microsoft’s Edge browser since it went through various tweaks and updates recently. In addition, Microsoft claims that using Edge will give users forty-five percent more battery life compared to similar devices using Chrome. However, because of its popularity and efficient algorithm, most of us prefer Google to Bing regarding Internet searches.

Price

Regarding the hardware, there is not much difference between the supported devices of both OSes. You can purchase a Chromebook for as cheap as $179, while the Windows 10 S laptops will start at $189, with the latter scheduled to start shipping this summer.

Applications

Both operating systems offer a wide variety of applications. Microsoft claims there are 669,000 applications in the Windows Store. On the other hand, the Google Play Store has more apps. We can say that neither OS suffers from the lack of applications.

One advantage ChromeOS has over Windows 10 S is the ability to install Android apps on Chromebook. Not all Android apps will work on Chromebook, though, but that still give its users more app choices than Windows 10 S.

Here’s a table to sum up the differences.

 Windows 10 SChrome OS
Application InstallFrom the hard driveFrom the internet
Search EngineBingGoogle
Internet BrowserMicrosoft EdgeGoogle Chrome
Price of laptopStarting from $189Starting from $179
Store used to download appsWindows StoreGoogle Play Store
Ability to run Android appsNoYes

It is hard to tell which operating system works the best for everyone. For those who are used to Microsoft’s dominant desktop OS and do not seek to conduct almost every activity on the Web, we recommend Windows 10 S. On the other hand, Chrome OS uses a wider selection of apps and hardware, and is a better choice for browsers and search engines.

Which one would you choose?

9 comments

  1. Why anyone would use such restrictive platforms is beyond my comprehension. Unless you are an obedient, compliant consumer, that is. Baaaa.

  2. For people that aren’t, or don’t want to be, a ‘techie’, Chromebooks offer useful access to most of their internet needs while eliminating the hassle of updating the OS and some sort of Anti-virus. I made my choice shortly after purchasing one of the first chromebooks available. It was an experiment at first and over time it has become my primary pc. (I still have mostly unused Macs and Win machines.) I didn’t have to make a choice concerning Google vs. Microsoft because it was a choice of one. However, should MS have been there I still wouldn’t have picked them. Win has always been a platform forced on me; not one that I wanted. I’ve been annoyed by MS’s business practices since the early DOS days and it has never gotten better. I don’t care how good Win gets, I’ll never want to use it and now that I’m retired it can’t be forced on me. One of my retirement ‘hobbies’ is converting Win users into chromebook users. They are usually thrilled with the ease of maintaining their new machine and the much reduced worrying about malware. Some keep their old Win machine to run legacy programs. They can usually disconnect those pcs from the internet to remove some of those malware worries.

    Google builds products for end users. MS builds products for the benefits of companies, not the end users.

    • “One of my retirement ‘hobbies’ is converting Win users into chromebook users.”
      IOW, you take them from the embrace of one monopoly (Win) and deliver them into the embrace of another monopoly (Google). Gee, what a friend!

  3. So, like me you dislike having to conform to Microsoft’s business plan, but don’t you think Google’s plan is also one of market domination? Try using any Google product without a Google account and you see what I mean. My answer is Linux, and eventually found the Mint version suitable. I abandoned Windows completely after about a week of Linux, I did however make sure I didn’t lose any important data before wiping out the cursed MS! Now after two months in, I’m exploring other linux systems, all on the same machine. Fascinating!

        • The last time I checked out a Ubuntu-based distro, all software installed by default, had ‘ubuntu-minimal’ file as a dependency. “Ubuntu-minimal’ is one of the system files. If you try to uninstall any unwanted software, such as unwanted language packs or ‘cowsay’ or ‘fortune’ , ‘ubuntu-minimal’ would be uninstalled too and your system would become inoperable. Just like with Windows. Whatever programs are installed by default, you better leave alone.

          Unwanted language packs, unwanted printer, video and other hardware drivers total up to almost 1 GB of space. Linux is supposedly about choice. If I choose to uninstall software that I don’t need or want, I should be able to do so. Ubuntu-based distros take that choice away from me.

  4. Microsoft opens up the coffin again. A Windows 8 looking vampire, called Windows 10 S, jumps out to drink PC users’ blood and drain their pockets once again. No, thanks. I have seen this movie too many times.

  5. I want an email system that would allow me to make my own “friend’s list” ie one where I could block or detour everything not sent by peeps on my “preferred list, thereby making it easier to multi-delete any and all unsolicited email.

    Other than that, how about an option to post comments w/o leaving my email address

Comments are closed.

Sponsored Stories